Meta Monday: Blubber, Blood, Muscle and Bone

why-read-moby-dickI’ve been reading Nathaniel Philbrick’s Why Read Moby Dick? I highly recommend it—but this passage brought me up short:

The White Whale is not a symbol. He is as real as you or I. He has a crooked jaw, a humped back, and a wiggle-waggle when he’s really moving fast. He is a thing of blubber, blood, muscle and bone—a creation of the natural world that transcends any fiction. So forget about trying to figure out what the White Whale signifies.

Um, while I admire and appreciate both your knowledge and your insights, Mr. Philbrick, please don’t give me direct orders on how to interpret a novel. I get that in in this story world, Moby Dick is an actual whale. I don’t question that. What I do question, however, is how Ahab understands this animal.

Okay. So Moby Dick is a powerful, terrifying whale who tore off Ahab’s leg. But is that exclusively how Ahab sees him? When he starts his crazy, fanatical hunt for vengeance, is it all about the whale?

Maybe. I don’t think there’s a right or wrong answer here.

We can mostly agree that Ahab is obsessed with revenge against this wicked dangerous animal, right?  (Well, wicked dangerous to the humans who try to hunt him down—it’s not like Moby Dick is purposely seeking out humans to attack. But that’s another issue.) But is Ahab furious only with the whale? Or does the whale represent, to him, something bigger? Or maybe Someone bigger?

That’s how I read it. I think, yeah, Ahab wants to kill this whale or die trying. Moby Dick the animal, I mean. But I also think there’s more going on for him.

Going after the animal who tore off his leg is really a way of declaring war on the God who allowed that to happen—the God who didn’t stop this creature from sort of emasculating him. Or maybe he’s warring against an impersonal Fate. Or maybe he’s warring against Reality Itself. You know, the way things are. (God, Fate, Reality—I don’t fret over these distinctions.)

Meanwhile, I have no idea if that’s how Melville saw Ahab. Melville never spelled out the crazy captain’s psychology, which is part of what makes the book so intriguing. But, at the very least, I think Melville left us with room for speculation. Room to view Moby Dick as a real whale and, at the same time, as a symbol for something even greater. Or Someone even more awe-inspiring.

Or a different interpretation altogether.

About Jenn Moss

Author * Web Serialist * Virtual Addict
This entry was posted in Meta, Meta Mondays and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Meta Monday: Blubber, Blood, Muscle and Bone

  1. Grandtrines says:

    Reblogged this on Still Another Writer's Blog.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Quintessential Editor says:

    I absolutely agree with your response to the provided excerpt. Don’t tell us how to live our lives!

    I also really enjoyed your thoughts. This book was one of those books I was forced to read in school, hated, then re-read later in life and enjoyed. I mostly hated it (the first time) because there was a teacher there, sitting on my shoulder, telling me how I should think about the book, instead of letting me find my own way through it.

    I agree with your interpretation of the main concept of the book. Man versus god and all of that. A lot of people talk about the four kinds of conflicts: man v. man, society, nature, himself/herself. I think what makes this book intriguing (for me at least) is the conflicts within touch on all of these dimensions on some level.

    Thanks for sharing your musings!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Jenn Moss says:

      Ack! Sorry you had such a bad experience with Moby Dick the first time around. Teachers like that are so frustrating. I’m glad I never read it in school, so I never ran into that situation.

      That said, I didn’t fully appreciate it my first time around either. I fell in love with the opening chapters, didn’t understand much of the rest, and pretty much just wanted to write AU fan fics about Ishmael and Queequeg living happily ever after together. (Okay. I still want to write those fics.)

      Now I can appreciate much more of the breadth, depth and large-heartedness of Melville’s vision . . . however much he meanders along the way.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s